All Cookies are $5 Each and just shy of 1/2 pound.
Classic Chocolate Chip Cookie
The foundation of our mighty empire. The perfect balance of chocolate and vanilla rolled in more chocolate and topped with coarse sea salt. Winner of countless awards ranging from best in Florida to best in the World! 🥇🍪🌎
Cookies & Cream
What if you took the chocolate chips out of the chocolate chip cookies, replaced them with hand cut chunks of double stuffed cookies & cream and rolled the dough in crushed cookie crumbs? BAM! The perfect cookies & cream cookie!
Triple Chocolate Chip
Our Triple Chocolate (which is really 5 kinds of chocolate) is made with fancy Callebaut and Ghirardelli chocolates to name a few. To make is extra velvety we pour our chocolate ganache straight into the cookie dough as we're mixing it. Our most emotional cookie.
Candied Walnut Chocolate Chip
We don't like walnut cookies! They get rubbery in cookies as soft and buttery as ours. So we made the walnut cookie great again by topping it with our double baked Candied Walnuts and hand placing each one all over the top of our Classic Chocolate Chip Cookie. Add it to your Preorder any day or find it in our shop every "Walnut Wednesday".
Pistachio Toffee Dark Chocolate
A favorite in Gideon's kitchen, this flavorful cookie mixes our favorite dark chocolate chunks with toffee bites. Top that off with lightly salted pistachios and perfection is achieved. Known for being our most sophisticated flavor, this is the cookie that the Orlando Weekly suggests you try first.
Peanut Butter Crisp
The newest cookie at Gideon's because you demanded it! Our smooth Peanut Butter Cookie is filled with PB Chips and our house made Candied Peanuts with caramelized Vanilla Butter Crisps sprinkled throughout for added crunch!
Coffee Cake Cookie (August Limited)
We're in love. The Coffee Cake Cookie is an extra Buttery Vanilla Bean Cookie filled with Cinnamon Walnut Strudel and topped with our Homemade Butter Crumbs! It’s amazingly delicious with a coffee from our East End Market neighbors Lineage Coffee. Available NOW and for the rest of the month every day while supplies last! Limit 2 per person!
When an entire cookie is just too much or you need to take your cookie experience to the next level we present to you our Cookie Bites. These "Bites" are quartered Gideon's Cookies completely dipped in chocolate and sprinkled with toppings. Mix & Match with your Preorder. Perfect for events. Perfect for gifts. Perfect with great coffee. Perfect.
These flavors are only available once a year! They can not be preordered and are only listed here to build anticipation.
Triple Chocolate Chipotle Dark Chocolate Covered Cherry ( February)
The Valentines month cookie is pure Decadence! A Triple Chocolate Cookie topped with Chipotle Dark Chocolate Covered Cherries all the way from Pike Place Market in Seattle. It’s a deep chocolate flavor with a nice subtle heat and cherry infusion.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Swirl (Random)
For the month of May Only! This almost 1/2 pound beast is a combo of both our popular Peanut Butter dough swirled with our super velvety Triple Chocolate dough. Top them both with all the Chocolate Chips and Peanut Butter Chips and House-made Candied Peanuts and 💥 you’ve got perfection!
Coffee Toffee Chocolate Chip (RANDOM)
A new crowd favorite! Filled and topped with freshly ground beans from our friends at Lineage Coffee Roasting and complimented with notes of Toffee and Chocolate in our Vanilla Bean Cookie!
Roasted Coconut Caramel Chocolate Chip (Random)
This beauty is a Caramel laced Chocolate Chip Cookie topped with Shaved Roasted Coconut! None of that weird chewy coconut here! Fresh and delicious!
Rocky Road (Random)
Imagine a world where the Gideon's Triple Chocolate Chip Cookie gets loaded with Candied Almonds and Torched Marshmallows. Can you see it in your minds eye? That's the Rocky Road.
The Frankenstein (October)
Our most popular and irresponsible cookie of the year! The Frankenstein is made of pieces parts of favorite traditional goodies and topped with M&M's that we lovingly place on the top OCD style to be sure you get all the colors. Inside you'll find crushed Oreo Double Stuff and Chocolate Pieces. ⚡️
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut with Homemade Salted Caramel (November)
We can't just give you a standard White Chocolate Cookie! Our homemade Salted Caramel is what makes this cookie so extra special. The caramel bakes right in and sometimes even explodes right out to offer you a cookie that is fun and packed with flavors. A Gideon's Team favorite!
Triple Chocolate Salted Andes Mint (December)
All the goodness of our rich Triple Chocolate cookie with the added bonus of cool and refreshing chopped Andes Mints. During the 16 hour process we take to make our cookies that mint soaks into every ounce of the chocolate dough making the perfect chocolate mint explosion with every bite!!
The Hermit (Random)
The most popular cookie in the late 1800's was called the Hermit. This spiced cookie was improved by Gideon when he added chunks of chocolate to compliment the cinnamon and nutmeg.
Peanut Butter Espresso (Random)
A creamy Peanut Butter mixed with freshly ground 431 blend Espresso from the award winning Lineage Coffee. Topped with chocolate and our small batch house made candied peanuts for the perfect amount of crunch with your cookie.
All cakes are 8 inches and triple layered. Serves up to 20 people.
We won't lie, this one is our favorite. Most Red Velvet you find these days is just chocolate cake with red food coloring but our masterpiece is a traditional buttermilk based cake. Insanely moist and heavily layered with the best cream cheese frosting then covered in our candied walnuts.
Cookies & Cream
The ultimate cake for the C&C fan. This 12 pound cake starts with our classic chocolate cake and is thickly frosted with our special C&C icing. In-between each layer you will find a bed of chopped cookies and the entire cake is covered in our signature chocolate ganache. Oh yea ... more crushed cookies go on top. Why not?
Melt in your mouth chocolate cake covered in Salted Caramel Frosting with our homemade Salted Caramel poured in-between each and every layer. A favorite in the Gideon's kitchen!
3 Layer Chocolate Chip Cake
If you can't decide between one of our chocolate cakes or cookies then combine the two! Each layer of chocolate cake is layered with chopped chocolate chip cookies over the vanilla bean frosting. Boom, topped with chocolate ganache and more chopped cookies. Intense!
Peanut Butter Cup
Chocolate and Peanut Butter at its finest. Our 3 layer chocolate cake with a perfect PB Buttercream. In between every layer of cake is a layer of crushed Peanut Butter Cups. Then some ganache and more PB Cups and you've got a Gideon's Bakehouse Peanut Butter Cup cake!
If you dream of chocolate throughout your day then this cake is your soul mate. Moist chocolate cake with deep chocolate frosting layered with chocolate cookies and chips then covered in our, you guessed it, chocolate ganache.
Andes Mint Cookies & Cream Cake
The popular holiday cake is now here all year because you demanded it! 3 Layer Chocolate Cake with Mint Cookies & Cream Buttercream and filled throughout with crushed Andes Mint! It's just perfect.
Birthday for the chocolate cake fan! Chocolate cake with vanilla bean frosting topped with chocolate ganache! Available with Chocolate or Vanilla Bean Frosting.
Pie & Cookie Cake
Check for availability
PB Apple Pie
This pie is so good we don't offer any other pies! You won't believe how beautifully our Peanut Butter Sauce tastes over a bed of crisp Apple. Top it all with a crumb coating and you have a pie that tastes amazing hot, cold, or room temperate. CURRENTLY UNAVAILABLE
Giant Gideon's Cookie
What is this? A super giant cookie? One Dozen cookies form up to make one giant 8 inch cookie cake! We accent it with little buttercream frosting and our famous sprinkle of sea salt.
Dessert Iced Coffee (NOT CURRENTLY AVAILABLE)
16oz bottle $4 each / Dairy Free
The Original Peanut Butter Iced Coffee
You can't live life without trying this. Our special cold brewed coffee expresso syrup combined with smooth almond milk and light roasted peanuts. You'll wonder where this has been your whole life. Seriously. It's good.
Fire and Iced Coffee
What happens when you mix our expresso coffee syrup with our mocha cacao mix that we've infused with habanero pepper? The result is a perfect mocha cold coffee that finishes with a warmth at the back of your throat. Indeed.